
In our continuing effort to bring transparency to the marketplace, we felt that it was time to tackle one of the most commonly misunderstood aspects of selling one’s jewelry - the role of the retail replacement appraisal. This is the document that you receive or pay for after you’ve purchased a piece of jewelry. At CIRCA, we spend a lot of time discussing with our clients the significance of appraisals in determining resale value. Here are two of the most common misconceptions:
Misconception 1: The offer you receive for your jewelry should be about 50% of the appraisal value.
Reality: Contrary to popular belief, there is no magic formula to determine what percentage of your appraisal you should “get back” when selling your jewelry. That’s because there is no standard methodology for appraising an item. In fact, we often see differing appraisal values for similar, if not exactly the same, items. Yes, appraisals are important in protecting your purchase, but they can not be used to determine the resale value of that item.
Misconception 2: An appraisal represents the current value of an item.
Reality: An appraisal is obtained primarily for insurance purposes, and represents the replacement value of an item, or what the item can be bought for new, if you should need to replace it because of loss or theft. As such, the appraisal value is typically an inflated number that allows you to replace your jewelry in a retail environment. While appraisals are useful for this purpose, they don’t speak to the actual “value” of the item, meaning what someone is willing to pay for that specific item.
Keep in mind the true value of something, jewelry or otherwise, is always based on supply and demand. Old, rare, or signed pieces of jewelry have high demand and limited supply, thus driving prices up. Lesser quality, mass produced jewelry is readily available, which translates to a lower price.